Your CEO Says You Need More “Executive Presence”: Here’s What They Might Really Mean
The 360 Leadhership Podcast, Episode , 04 November 2026 by Lucy Gernon
Has your manager ever told you, “I think you need to work on your executive presence”… and then left you wondering what on earth that actually means?
Here’s the thing, executive presence is important, particularly for women in leadership. But “you need more executive presence” is incredibly vague feedback.
And when you’re already prone to overthinking, vague feedback can send you into a full leadership development strategy in your head.
In this episode of The Lucy Gernon Show, I’m breaking down four things your manager or CEO might actually mean when they tell you to work on your executive presence.
We’ll talk about communication, authenticity, confidence and the mindset shifts that can help you stop trying to “fix” yourself and start understanding the specific gap you need to close.
Because executive presence isn’t about being louder, more polished or pretending to be someone you’re not.
It’s about how your competence lands in the room.
🎧 Tune in to Discover:
- What does “executive presence” actually mean?
- Stop turning feedback into “I’m not good enough”
- Why executives need you to get to the point faster
- Why authenticity matters more than ever
- What real executive confidence looks like
RECOMMENDED NEXT STEPS
👉 Take the free Executive Presence Gap Assessment to help you identify the areas you may need to develop.
👉 What Happens When High-Achieving Women Stop Waiting for Permission with Lisa Nash, Terry O’Laoghaire and Karen Ryan
Prefer to read?
Lucy (00:00)
What do you do when your manager sits you down and says, I think you need to work in your executive presence? Do you smile? Do you nod? You probably say, Okay, absolutely, that’s really useful feedback. And then you walk out of the room thinking, What the hell does that actually mean? Am I not confident enough? Did I talk too much? Do I not look like an executive? Do I need to be more assertive, polished, strategic? Do I need to somehow magically develop more gravitas before the next executive meeting?
And underneath all of those questions can be the one that you probably don’t want to admit. Does my manager think I am good enough to lead at this level? Now, lovely lady, if you’ve ever received feedback about your executive presence, especially if you’ve been promoted to a VP, senior director, or executive level role, this is the episode for you. This week’s episode of the Lucy Gernon Show, we are diving into all of this.
Because sometimes when your CEO tells you that you need more executive presence or your manager, they’re not actually questioning whether you’re good enough at your job. They may actually be telling you that there is a gap between how competent you are and how that competence is actually landing at executive level. And that’s a very, very different problem. So today I want to unpack four things that your manager might actually mean when they tell you that you need to work in your executive presence. Because before you start trying to fix yourself, let’s understand the gap.
Hi there and welcome back to another episode of the Lucy Garnan Show. We are here in season three. I’m your host, Lucy Garnan, a multi-war meeting executive coach, and just a normal mom of three who happen to work in the corporate world and who happens to absolutely love coaching women and senior leadership. And today we are talking all about executive presence and more specifically, what the bloody hell people actually mean when they tell you that you need more of it. Because I have a bit of an issue when you get this kind of feedback.
And it’s not that executive presence isn’t important. Of course, it absolutely is. For any female leader to be taken seriously at any level, you’ve got to have that presence that commands attention, that you know, demands respect and that brings people along. But because people throw that phrase around all the time without explaining what they actually mean, it drives me crazy. You need more executive presence. Okay, thank you, Susan. Would you care to elaborate?
Because that could actually mean about 57 different things. And when vague feedback is given to high performers like you who already have a tendency to overthink, my God, you can create an entire leadership development strategy in your head based on one sentence. Suddenly you’re analyzing your clothes, your voice, your slides, where you sit, your body language. Did you speak too much? Did you speak too little? Did you smile? Did you not smile? And
The irony of all of this self-monitoring is that it can actually make you appear less confident, less competent, not more. So today I would like to take some of the mystery out of this for you. And as you’re listening, I invite you to be asking yourself, where is my executive presence gap? Because that’s going to be different for every single woman listening to this show today. And I’ve actually created an executive presence gap assessment to help you to identify exactly that.
So if this episode starts hitting home and you want to know what your executive presence gaps are, head over to lucygernon.com forward slash gap and you can grab this assessment tool that I’ve developed based on the latest Harvard research on exactly what executive leaders and CEOs are looking for and the traits that they say are the most important for executive presence. I’ll link it in the show notes, but if you want to grab it now, you can go to lucygernon.com forward slash gap.
Now, let me tell you about a conversation with one of my 360 Leaders Club ladies that inspired a lot about what I would like to share with you today. So I was coaching this fantastic woman who had recently stepped into an executive role, and she sits on the team, and I think there were about seven others on the team with her, and she’s one of the newest members, and of course, she’s a woman and she’s younger than some of them. And she came into 360 Leaders Club partly because
She had been given the feedback that she needed to work in her presence. And she also felt very, you know, out of her depth in the role. And what I found really interesting is that, you know, I could clearly see why she was promoted. She is, she’s got like a magnetic presence about her. You can tell she’s the kind of leader that you would want to work for. She knew her content, her expertise were amazing. And
You know, she was promoted internally because the CEO actually really believed in her, and so did her manager. And this was not not about her capability. It was really because she got some feedback that she needed to work in her presence. And she turned that into, I’m not good enough. And if that’s you, I want you to know that that is just really not helpful because we’ve got to be able to get out of our emotional brain as women.
And get more into our logical brain. And don’t take that as you’re not good enough for the role. Just really see that as an area for development. And now I know you might be sitting there thinking, Of course I do that. Do you? Really? Because none of us really like to get that feedback. I know I certainly, as much as I preach about feedback and receiving it, like it still cuts me deep. Like if a client isn’t happy or if I haven’t provided the best experience for my 360 Leaders Club members.
And I have to remind myself that you know, feedback is part of business and it’s it’s always an opportunity for you to grow and learn. And one thing I know about you for sure is that you are heart led and you care deeply about your role. You also want to have financial security for your family, you want to have an amazing retirement. So it’s really important that you perform at the executive level and that you feel confident and
God forbid that you actually enjoy it along the way because you don’t have to spend your life, you know, replaying that information that you were given in that feedback. Because if they believe you can operate at this level, so should you. Because
You know, I think it’s like if you’re able to think about, come out of your own body and you look at okay, what are they specifically seeing in me? What is happening when I communicate and you start watching the room, how am I being experienced by other people and what might need to evolve now that I’m in this new role and what what my you know what my audience need, because that is where that self reflection comes from, right? You’ve got to start to be able to come out of yourself and worried about you and really make it all about your own audience, okay?
So when it comes to executive presence, sometimes you need to get to your point faster.
Executives and CEOs usually need less information, not more. And I know it can feel quite counterintuitive because obviously you need to have business cases and obviously you need to have data and obviously you need to be explained, able to explain clearly and concisely where there’s delays or what the risks are or you know what this the strategy is and all of those things. But instead of thinking about it in you know in in the level of detail, it’s about coming up
out of the detail and start thinking about how does this actually relate to the big picture. Because if you spent your career building credibility through your expertise, your instinct is probably more about more information equals more credibility, more detail, more preparation, more data gives you more certainty, more slides equals, well, I’ve done my homework and I’m ready. But CEOs and boards and executive audiences don’t always experience it that way. Now I’m not for a minute and
saying that you don’t need detail in the background, I’m not saying that. But what I’m saying is that you’ve got to be able to read the room and understand what your leaders need. And even if your CEO or whoever you’re presenting to is very detail oriented, you need to be able to cut through the detail to give them it the bottom line. Like I always think of an Excel Excel spreadsheet. Are you telling them cell by cell, column by column, or are you starting with the bottom line? So that’s one thing from an executive
presence perspective is communication is one of the the key traits for executive presence and communication comes with you know using your body language and watching others’ body language communicating with impact it doesn’t mean you have to be loud it doesn’t mean you have to over talk but it does mean that you need to be able to communicate in a way that lands with your audience okay the other thing from an executive presence that’s really
becoming more and more important is authenticity. So years ago, authenticity, when Harvard did this study 10 years ago, authenticity didn’t even register as a factor for executive presence. But now with Gen Alpha and Gen Z and all of these younger ones that are coming up behind us, like they can smell the bullshit. And you’re probably seeing that now more and more that they’re more focused on work-life balance. They’re not as into their careers as we were
And that requires a different way of leading. And as well, people they want more authenticity, they want more you. I’m just thinking of one of my members in 360 Terry. She actually recorded an episode with us on the podcast last season. We can link that for you in the show notes. It was in season two. I think it was the second last episode or the last episode. Second last episode. If you just go back, you’ll see it. And
she was so brave that she she shared about how she really wanted to lead authentically and she was so not afraid but like fearful of really putting herself out there because she’s a mom and she sometimes as women we try to hide the fact that we’re mothers in the workplace so we’re taken more seriously and we don’t get penalized. But one thing she really wanted to do was to actually to just lead us herself. And when she did, she got promoted. She got promoted to managing director, she’s doing really, really well. And
When you lead authentically, you give other people permission to do the same. Because personally I know, like I am not for everyone, you know, none of us are. But I know that I inspire other people to be authentic because I am very, very authentic, right? It’s not that you have to like the person, it’s not none of that. But it’s just my invitation for you is that you are you. And when you are you, the most magnetic opportunities will happen for you. That is when you oo presence because you’re so grounded and
Sure of who you are and what you bring to the table. Okay. And then the other point in executive presence is confidence is the number one trait of executive presence. Of all the CEOs and executives that were surveyed as part of this Harvard study, they all said I think it was like 78% was confidence. And confidence is not something that you can fake, and confidence is absolutely not over talking. Confidence is being comfortable in silence.
Confidence is being comfortable knowing what you don’t know. Confidence is taking a risk and being willing to accept the consequences, knowing that you did it for the right reasons. Confidence is trusting yourself more. And again, being willing to fail and own that failure. You know, if you listen to Simon Seneca at all, he talks a lot about this in terms of the most
You know, he was talking about great leaders. I saw a clip on Instagram and he was talking about the one trait like leadership is not about being loud or being very, you know, gravitas is not all about being magnetic and charismatic. He said the best leaders, they all have one trait in common, and that’s courage. The courage to be yourself, the courage to lead authentically, the courage to get it wrong and own what you got wrong. Because when you are able to do that and you’re so
sure of who you are and what you bring to the table. That is an executive presence that is magnetic because you are showing up fully as yourself. And when you show up fully as yourself and really own who you are and what you bring, regardless of who is in the room, you will stand out. Okay. You will stand out. Now there’s eight different areas of executive presence and in the gap assessment tool that I’ve developed you can go and grab that at lucygernon.com forward slash gap.
And you can have a look at and see, okay, which are the areas that you need to develop in when it comes to your executive presence. I’ve literally broken down the eight areas for you. It is, it couldn’t be more clear. My logical people will be very happy to know this. It is very tangible, it’s not some elusive concept, and there are ways you can absolutely work in them. So head over to lucygernon.com forward slash gap, and you can grab your executive presence gap assessment tool right there with my compliments. All right. So that is it for this week’s episode of the Lucy Gernon Show.
I hope that this has been valuable for you. I hope you have a bit more of an understanding of what executive presence is, and definitely go and grab that gap assessment tool. It’ll be super helpful for you. And in the meantime, I invite you to take a step back after you do the assessment and really look at if there was one area that you could improve on for yourself, what would it be? And before you say I am confident, are you confident not knowing? Are you confident in conflict? Are you confident when
You take a risk and it doesn’t work out. Because if the answers are no, that’s an area that we need to work on, and that’s okay. So if there’s another female leader that you know who needs to hear this episode who doesn’t fully get what executive presence is either, please share it with her. Please subscribe to the show. And if you have enjoyed this show, please rate it and review it. I would so appreciate it. It would really, really helps me to bring these episodes to more
Women.
So that is it for this week’s episode of the show. I have to go now and bring my daughter swimming. It is a Friday evening as I’m recording this, and I just wanted to do it, so I had it done. I have to go bring her swimming and then I’m going to go out for some food with my husband and then chill for the evening. So whatever you’re up to today, when this comes out, will be a Wednesday, midweek hump. Take some time for yourself, lovely lady. Go and grab that gap assessment. Go and put you first because remember, the detail isn’t always needed. Sometimes it is about being strategic.
Getting up out of the weeds and focusing on you. All right. See you then again next week. Same time, same place. Bye for now.